Should You Let Your Marketplace Plan Auto-Renew for 2027?
Auto-renewal keeps you covered, but it can also leave you paying more than you need to. Here is how it works for 2027 and a quick way to compare before you stay.
Short answer: auto-renewal is a safety net, not a good deal. It can keep you covered if you do nothing, but in a year when benchmark premiums are rising about 13% on average, the plan you stay in may no longer be your best price. Comparing takes less time than you might expect.
What happens if you do nothing
If you have a Marketplace plan in December and don’t choose a plan or end coverage by December 15, HealthCare.gov generally re-enrolls you. Three details catch people out:
- It may not be the same plan. You could be moved to a different plan from your insurer. If your insurer isn’t offering plans in your area next year, you’ll be matched with a plan from a different company.
- You still have to pay. Your new plan doesn’t start until you pay your first monthly premium.
- Your savings may run on old information. If you don’t update your application, your tax credit can be estimated from older data. You could get too little help each month, or get too much and owe it back at tax time.
Why your price can change even if your plan doesn’t
Your premium tax credit isn’t tied to the plan you pick. It’s tied to the benchmark plan, the second-lowest-cost Silver plan in your area. When your own plan rises faster than the benchmark, you pay the difference. KFF reports that benchmark premiums are up about 13% on average for 2027, but your area and your plan can land far from that average.
Here’s a made-up example for someone expected to pay $300 a month toward the benchmark:
| Full premium | Tax credit | You pay per month | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026: your plan, which was the benchmark | $600 | $300 | $300 |
| 2027: same plan, auto-renewed | $720 | $378 | $342 |
| 2027: switch to the new benchmark | $678 | $378 | $300 |
In this example, staying put costs $504 more over the year for a plan at the same metal level. Real numbers vary by age, income and ZIP code, and a cheaper plan may have a different network or drug list, which is why the steps below matter.
A five-step comparison before you stay
- Update your income and household. Marketplace savings are based on what you expect to earn in 2027, not on last year. Starting with 2026 coverage, there’s no cap on how much extra tax credit you may have to repay, so a good estimate matters.
- Read your renewal notice. Look for your 2027 premium, deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, then note what changed.
- Compare yearly cost, not just the monthly bill. Add up 12 months of premiums, then add what you’d likely spend on care. Our metal tier comparison and cost calculator can help.
- Check your doctors and prescriptions again. Networks and drug lists change every year, even within the same plan. Here’s how to check them.
- Look at Silver if your income is under 250% of the poverty level. That’s the only tier with cost-sharing reductions, which lower your deductible and out-of-pocket costs.
When staying put makes sense
Keeping your plan can be the right choice. If it’s still competitively priced, keeps your doctors and covers your medications, and your income hasn’t changed much, you may not gain much by switching. The point is to make that choice on purpose. If you do stay, update your application so your tax credit is right.
Dates to know on HealthCare.gov
- December 15, 2026: last day to pick or change a plan for coverage starting January 1.
- January 15, 2027: open enrollment ends. Choosing a plan after December 15 and by this date means coverage starts February 1.
States that run their own Marketplace can set different dates, so check yours if you don’t use HealthCare.gov. After open enrollment ends, you generally can’t change plans unless you have a qualifying life event.
Want someone to run the comparison for you? A licensed agent can check your renewal against the other plans in your ZIP code, including your doctors and prescriptions, at no cost to you. Request a free quote.
Sources
- HealthCare.gov, Keep or change your plan
- HealthCare.gov, Dates and deadlines
- KFF, 9 things to watch for the 2027 ACA open enrollment period (October 30, 2026)
- IRS, Repayment caps eliminated for excess advance premium tax credit
Facts checked November 4, 2026. The example is for illustration only and isn’t a quote.